Temp.Assistance Program East (TAPE)
valet at vms.biochem.mpg.de
Fri Feb 7 06:48:34 EST 1997
In amplifying on Spizek's and Paul's concern, I want to
contribute a few thoughts and proposals.
As a person who has conscientiously seen the end of world war II
and personally experienced the difficulties of the postwar period,
I believe, the temporary assistance to Eastern European scientists, constitutes
a high moral duty to us. It seems fundamentally important to help those
who in spite of unpaid salaries, non entertained buildings and outdated
instrumentation remain attached in thinking and action to their scientific
Outstanding scientists are working in or have come from these
countries and during better times, these regions have actively
contributed over long periods to the extension of worldwide
scientific knowledge. Our intended effort should therefore aim to
maintain and extend the intellectual attachment of Eastern European
scientists to the current developments in our discipline during the
present economic depression in these countries.
While it is certainly neither within the capacity of individual scientists
nor of scientific organisations like ISAC or national cytometric societes to
replace missing research budgets, the maintenance of the intellectual
attachement by electronic networking seems a comparatively feasable
and centrally appropriate task for us scientists as genuine carriers
of the present intellectual and experimental knowledge.
Before elaborating an action plan, such a program should be clearly
identifyable by a forward directing name. Temporary Assistance
Program East (TAPE) or Paul's more general Scientist Assistance
Program (SAP) seem reasonable approximations to our intentions.
The following actions seem profitable to Eastern European scientists
and feasable by us:
1. to *distribute* the Purdue CD with its original or slightly modified
content. The CD could additionally contain the table of contents and
the abstracts of Cytometry and CCC (by kind permission of J.Wiley)
and ACP (IOS-Press) in addition to the generously offered but
nevertheless more cost limited numbers of copies of both journals
provided free of charge by either Wiley/Liss or by ISAC/CCS.
2. to *collect* E-mail addresses of Eastern European scientists
and of cytometry organisations or local interest groups e.g. around
larger cities in these countries.
3. to *install* E-mail servers in adjacent countries profiting from the fast
access lines i.e. in Germany and Austria. These mail servers could
be operated in English but more realistically in the respective native
or in a split mode. Their Internet transcripts could be displayed or
mirrorred on the
CytoRelay or Purdue Internet nodes. This would permit the intercommunication of
locally distant research groups and may facilitate the foundation (see e.g. EFCS
discussion experience at: http://www.biochem.mpg.de/valet/efcs.html) of
organisations in Eastern Europe. Such interest groups may be in many cases more
efficiently addressable e.g. for the organisation of courses, access to and
redistribution of information (e.g. CD's), generation of specific
the respective native languages etc. than individual scientists.
While the provision and maintenance of mail servers is comparatively
easily feasible e.g. via the Max-Planck-Gesellschaft in my personal case, the
production of *Internet transcripts* of the E-mail messages and their
the Internet *requires work* despite the existence of particular software
(e.g. at Purdue).
Considering, however, the *Off-line Internet* concept, explained
in: http://www.biochem.mpg.de/valet/offint1.html, agreed scientists in Eastern
European countries can prepare the transcripts of the radiated E-mail messages
themselves, zip and e-mail them to Paul or to me for a direct link into the
*CytoRelay* or *Purdue* nodes. One would in other words follow the same
procedure, presently used for the maintenance of the mutual CytoRelay/Purdue
www-mirrors. Once on the Internet, the information could be *incorporated*
into the regularly updated Purdue CD or onto a special East European CD.
A special CD may also be of interest to commerical companies for specific
product advertisement i.e. the production and distribution of the CDs could be
covered by industrial sponsors.
Native language pages should create a particular impact e.g. on US,
elsewhere located emigrant/immigrant scientists of these countries who will
intuitively develop a better feeling for the needs of their compatriotes.
4. to *collaborate* on the substantial problems of multiparameter data
analysis in conjunction with the intelligent computer interpretation of
such results. Many of us are aware of the traditionally very highly developed
mathematical disciplines in the Eastern European countries. Pairing the existing
experimental knowledge with their mathematical modelling expertise may well
generate entirely new concepts for multiparameter data processing and
interpretation. The inherent advantage of this is that one needs intellectual
concepts, experimental data and electronically linked PCs but not necessarily
high research budgets. I am personally trying to organize an electronic
collaboration with Prof.Zemskov and Dr.Vasilyev of the National Immunology
Institut in Moscow.
A particular stimulator towards such work could be a supplement in
"Current Concepts of Multiparameter Data Analysis in Cytometry" with the
inclusion of contributions from Eastern European Countries. This would
state of the art and emphasizes our concern for the joint development of more
efficient strategies of data analysis. Jan Visser and Brian Mayall as Cytometry
Editors are challenged at this point.
5. to *organize* cytometry related courses. The already existing practical
experience is that such activities are highly welcome to scientists in
Eastern countries. The lecturers so far cover the own travel costs from
their travel budgets, commercial companies provide instrumentation and
contribute financially to lower the local expenses of the course participants
An interesting option for the inclusion of qualified students or technicians
to operate the instrumentation or teach methodology at such courses may
exist e.g. during a holiday trip to Eastern Europe. ISAC could issue
certificates to individuals proposing themselves for such missions. Such
certificates seem helpful for further professional life as proof of personal
initiative and devotion to tasks of public interest.
6. to *provide* laptop and notebook computers which are too slow to
support e.g. time intensive computations e.g. under Windows95 but still
very useful for Internet access, data display, document editing, table
database operations and as network servers. It should be self evident that only
correctly functioning computers from e.g. 80486/487 processors upward
should be considered for such purposes. While the transport of the usual tower
computers with their heavy monitors is excluded for weight and space reasons,
laptop and notebook computers would be welcome as one piece equipement of
small size. The same is true for telephone modems or TCP/IP PCMCIA
or parallel interface plugin cards for network access.
The property transfer could be organized e.g. via publically registered
organisations like ISAC or DGZ into the property of Eastern European
While export regulations would in all likelihood not be against such
it will be important to clarify custom regulations before anything practical is
undertaken in this sense.
It seems evident from the above that substantial help can be given
for high a priori financing. Nevertheless we should not forget financial
remembering Spizek's earlier effort to collect money for such purposes, we
ask for industrial sponsoring of Spizek's ISAC account. As members of cytometric
societies we should furthermore urge the officiers in the various national
societies to establish *partnerships* with individual Eastern European
This would permit coorganisation of courses or meetings, personal invitations,
mailing of CDs or transport of PCs by the various societies in a forseeable and
not too costly manner. Such contacts will also establish the urgently needed
interpersonal relations, required for long term planning of joint research
e.g. within EU programs.
The Soros foundation for Eastern Europe may be approachable in addition,
and EU coordination program funds devoted to scientific contacts with Eastern
Europe may prove useful. Such action will, however, require longer time
for setup and visible signs of our efforts in the first place.
Without being exhaustive, I believe that a multitude of immediate and
actions can be taken by motivated scientists in this matter without a priori
need for a substantial financial assistance.
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Biochemie
Am Klopferspitz 18a
Tel: +49/89/8578-2518, -2525, Fax: +49/89/8578-2563
E-mail: valet at vms.biochem.mpg.de
J.Paul Robinson, Purdue University Cytometry Labs
Professor of Immunopharmacology
robinson at flowcyt.cyto.purdue.edu PH:317-494 6449 FAX:317-494 0517
More information about the Cytometry