[Citizendium-l] What are experts, again, and how do they work?
jawbrey at att.net
Fri Sep 22 00:42:07 EDT 2006
AG = Alex Golub
JA = Jon Awbrey
JA: You have well described a particular type of complex situation that does
arise on occasion, where well-informed people disagree for various reasons.
But that is not the typical sort of situation in WP that causes the lion's
share of the problems between more experienced and less experienced people.
In normal society, where all interested parties have a respect for knowledge,
the folks who truly want to learn what they do not know usually figure out
who has the goods on a given subject, and a transfer of information occurs
in the proper direction. And groups of specialists in different areas can
find ways to share so that everybody is enriched, if that is what everyone
desire more than a contest for which gang will be kings of the hill.
JA: Sad to say, that just doesn't happen in WP. There is some sort of ambient
field of forces that prevents it, some background permission to be pigheaded,
and I think that pig rots from the head. There are subjects that I've studied
for forty years, others where I had a decade of graduate courses and seminars.
I certainly have my disputes with other folks of equal experience, but never
anywhere else but WP have I had to sit and watch 2 folks who had a subject
waved over their heads once or twice in some intro course gang up and rip
to shreds an article that I put weeks or months of work into. That is
what happens on a day to day basis in WP. And the Admin Cabal seems
to enjoy watching the books burn for who the hell knows what reason.
inquiry e-lab: http://stderr.org/pipermail/inquiry/
wp review: http://wikipediareview.com/index.php?showuser=398
More information about the Citizendium-l